#tyndur · 2010-01-03
120 Nachrichten · Seite 1 von 1 · Original-CSV herunterladen
- quokheya pcmattman :)
- pcmattmanHi quok
- quokseems we've had a nice conversation via the mailing list about hotplugging :)
- pcmattmanYup, fairly successful one too
- pcmattmanSoon we'll be able to get the word out about CDI with a couple of reference implementations for perusal - that'll be a good day
- pcmattmanImagine being able to just write some glue code and instantly have access to any CDI driver in your own hobby OS
- pcmattmanIt's like the ultimate "get out of jail free" card for kids like TM :P
- quokyup, I'm quite excited about it :)
- quokand it's still much easier to follow than UDI
- pcmattmanI still don't get why I would need to write a metalanguage whatsit-called and a full IPC system just to use a UDI driver
- SHyx0rmZAnd I still have to do my implementation in ASM (just for the lulz) ;-)
- SHyx0rmZDo you mind giving me a link to the mailing list, I think I missed it
- pcmattmanWell, that's just the thing: you *can* implement CDI glue in assembly... I highly doubt you can do that with UDI
- quokSHyx0rmZ: http://list.tyndur.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/cdi-devel
- SHyx0rmZThank you
- pcmattmanDamn, that was fast
- pcmattmanquok's still the fastest gun in the west
- quok:)
- SHyx0rmZYou can do everything in assembly if you have enough time ;)
- pcmattmanMy current wireless hotspot gives ~4s of lag ;)
- pcmattmanWell, yes... Assembly can be used for anything, but you'd surely go insane before you completed a UDI assembly implementation
- pcmattmanA CDI assembly implementation would be quite enjoyable
- quokI especially like the way we're going about supporting hotplug
- quokit's just informing the OS of a new device, and the rest of it is rather OS defined, so we really don't have to worr about it
- quokfor OSes that don't support hotplug, it becomes a no-op
- pcmattmanRight
- pcmattmanHotplug is a *massive* bonus for OS's which decide to support it
- SHyx0rmZSounds easy enough
- pcmattmanPedigree already, for instance, has all the hooks in place for new disk devices to pop up and be linked straight into the VFS
- SHyx0rmZMy OS is far from handling disks at all :D
- pcmattmanWell, CDI can help with that :P
- SHyx0rmZI hope so
- SHyx0rmZAt least CDI will help rolling out my own filesystem
- SHyx0rmZAlthough I doubt anyone will have a use for it
- pcmattmanDepends on if you make the tools for said filesystem portable
- pcmattman;)
- SHyx0rmZIt's rather because of the way it works
- SHyx0rmZIt doesn't support traditional folders & files
- SHyx0rmZOr, rather, it will
- SHyx0rmZI'm not quite finished yet :D
- pcmattmanHeh, I see
- pcmattmanOne disadvantage to CDI is no binary compatibility
- pcmattmanOtherwise you could write a CDI driver for your FS and try it on a variety of CDI-supporting operating systems without a recompile
- SHyx0rmZI don't think that's a huge tradeoff, I don't care if I have to recompile a driver :D
- SHyx0rmZBut...
- pcmattmanHehe
- SHyx0rmZWould there be a possibly to still make if binary compatible at some point?
- pcmattmanWell, binary compatibility is not an easy thing to implement
- SHyx0rmZOr does the way CDI works already permit that
- pcmattmanI personally would like to see it at some point, but it doesn't seeem to look like it will happen very soon
- SHyx0rmZMake a CDI-VM :D
- pcmattmanIt would require some work to be portable across various types of OS
- quokwe'd kind of need a stable API at least to begin thinking about ABI issues :)
- pcmattmanFor example, tyndur is a microkernel, so its binaries are different to a monolithic one
- pcmattmanAnd yeah, a stable API is important
- SHyx0rmZHm, would it be possible to implement a CDI-VM as a CDI driver? oO
- quokwe need to ensure all the hotplug stuff works quite nicely in userspace :)
- pcmattmanIf it were to be implemented it would be after CDI was not changing so much (only recently did a fundamental part of CDI get rewritten)
- pcmattmanWe probably also need to finish some of the in-design and proposed subsystems, such as graphics and sound
- SHyx0rmZWould be great if there were a working VESA driver
- SHyx0rmZFor Long Mode that is
- pcmattmanRight, and that can come after the graphics subsystem is designed
- quokI thougth someone was working on that, actually?
- SHyx0rmZI'm really looking forward at implementing CDI, but I'm sure it will take me several months to understand it
- SHyx0rmZquok, I think so too
- pcmattmanquok: hm? Who?
- SHyx0rmZI know there is a VESA module in development for Týndur, but I don't know if it's written for CDI
- quokhttp://git.tyndur.org/?p=tyndur/alex.git;a=shortlog;h=refs/heads/video-devel
- pcmattmanMaybe I can work on documentation while I'm not properly internet-connected
- quokOh, I haven't bothered to look and see if it's being written for CDI. I think it is, though
- SHyx0rmZhttp://git.tyndur.org/?p=tyndur/alex.git;a=tree;f=src/modules/cdi/vesa;h=80273050d2ab4d60be355d245f6d3e3bba2028b1;hb=e6857c8907d43b8bf8e011afa4cd95a453d88c5f
- quokthere you have it, then :)
- SHyx0rmZAh, it looks like I'll have to do the implementation for Long Mode though
- SHyx0rmZTýndur's current implementation uses vm86 -.-
- quokeww :)
- pcmattmanHmm, I don't know many implementations which don't
- SHyx0rmZI think there aren't many people out there who develop x86-64 OSs
- FreakyPenguinMoin
- taljethXanClic: Ich habe schon verstanden, dass du im Wesentlich das gleiche sagst wie ich. Nur hast du es halt später gesagt als ich. ;-)
- XanClicAber so viel auch nicht ;-)
- taljethJedenfalls hast du erstmal geschrieben bevor du meine Mail gelesen hast, oder? ;-)
- XanClicNö
- XanClicNe, falschrum *g*
- XanClicJa ;-)
- FreakyPenguintaljeth: Ich habe jetzt nach einem git pull folgendes Problem in ata:
- FreakyPenguinmain.c:202: Fehler: Redefinition von »__cdi_driver___COUNTER__«
- FreakyPenguinmain.c:201: Fehler: Vorherige Definition von »__cdi_driver___COUNTER__« war hier
- XanClicDa hat das glue() wohl nicht so richtig funktioniert
- FreakyPenguinTut das bei dir? ;-)
- FreakyPenguinSieht so aus ;-)
- FreakyPenguinAh gcc-4.3....
- FreakyPenguinDas glue hat wohl doch funktioniert ;-)
- XanClicAber zu gut *g*
- taljethHm, und wer hat jetzt recht? ;-)
- XanClicDer Op in #lost hat immer recht ;-)
- FreakyPenguinIm Zweifelsfall ich ;-)
- quokMorning folks
- XanClicGood evening ;-)
- quokit's 9:50am here :)
- FreakyPenguinMorning ;-)
- XanClic4:50 pm here, nearly weekend-end
- taljethMoin
- taljethThat works always ;-)
- XanClic*g*
- quokI just checked my email. I kind of expected hotplugging patches from Matt :)
- taljethMaybe tomorrow
- taljethOr you could just do it yourself ;-)
- quokPerhaps I will get to work on it later. Still need to hammer out a few VMM bugs in QuokOS.
- quokbut before I can do that, I need to go finish working in my son's bedroom and get it all cleaned up so he has somewhere to sleep tonight. :)
- quokI suppose the sooner I get started on that, the sooner I can get finished and then get back to OS dev
- taljethI suppose you're right ;-)
- taljethAs always
- quokdon't let my wife know that. she has this crazy idea that she's the one that is always right!
- taljeth*lol*
- FreakyPenguin*g*
- quokokay, off I go!
- FreakyPenguinhf ;-)
- taljethAnd of course XanClic is going to tell you that it's the party that is always right ;-)
- XanClic:-P
- XanClicYou are a party? I didn't got that until now...